Perseverance
22/09/ · Second, I ponder how well the work that was conducted actually addresses the central question posed in the paper. (In my field, authors are under pressure to broadly sell their work, and it's my job as a reviewer to address the validity of such claims.) Third, I make sure that the design of the methods and analyses are appropriate. - McGlynn 26/01/ · If you are proposing that peer review comments make up a kind of 'summary' of the paper, that is not always the case. If a paper has minor amendments suggested the peer review comments could be just one or two lines for a paper which is thousands of words long. You'd still have to read the whole thing General Comments from Reviewer 1 Comment: This is an interesting study and the authors have collected a unique dataset using cutting edge methodology. The paper is generally well written and structured. However, in my opinion the paper has some shortcomings in regards to some data analyses and text, and I feel this unique datasetFile Size: KB
Post navigation
Reviewer 4 comments: Comment: This is an excellent report dealing with significant technical matters. I find no fault whatsoever with the methods, data analysis, or conclusions. The work, as with all work coming from this particular group, is fundamentally sound. My comments here are concerned solely with the organization of the blogger.com Size: KB 11/09/ · A Sample Response to the Comments of Peer Reviewers Edward Researcher Palaeography Institute Writer’s Lane South River, MI, USA, edresearcher@blogger.com Dr Helen Wordsmith Assistant Editor Journal of the Shipping Manuscripts Society Reader’s Row London, UK, SW6 9DE Undergraduate Papers. Sample Review of an Undergraduate Paper Level. This document contains excerpts of a level undergraduate paper with sample feedback from the Writing Center. Please click on the file to view. Sample Review of an Undergraduate Paper Level
Sample Paper Reviews: Overview
Undergraduate Papers. Sample Review of an Undergraduate Paper Level. This document contains excerpts of a level undergraduate paper with sample feedback from the Writing Center. Please click on the file to view. Sample Review of an Undergraduate Paper Level 26/01/ · If you are proposing that peer review comments make up a kind of 'summary' of the paper, that is not always the case. If a paper has minor amendments suggested the peer review comments could be just one or two lines for a paper which is thousands of words long. You'd still have to read the whole thing 06/09/ · The review process should help you to improve your paper. The review process is usually “blind”, so the reviewer will not know author names or affiliations. What you should do If you can fix the problem with your paper, then do so. If this requires more experimental research, ask the Editor before proceeding, and indicate the likely time frame
Tackling Reviewer Comments
Reviewer 4 comments: Comment: This is an excellent report dealing with significant technical matters. I find no fault whatsoever with the methods, data analysis, or conclusions. The work, as with all work coming from this particular group, is fundamentally sound. My comments here are concerned solely with the organization of the blogger.com Size: KB 22/09/ · Second, I ponder how well the work that was conducted actually addresses the central question posed in the paper. (In my field, authors are under pressure to broadly sell their work, and it's my job as a reviewer to address the validity of such claims.) Third, I make sure that the design of the methods and analyses are appropriate. - McGlynn 26/01/ · If you are proposing that peer review comments make up a kind of 'summary' of the paper, that is not always the case. If a paper has minor amendments suggested the peer review comments could be just one or two lines for a paper which is thousands of words long. You'd still have to read the whole thing
Undergraduate Papers. Sample Review of an Undergraduate Paper Level. This document contains excerpts of a level undergraduate paper with sample feedback from the Writing Center. Please click on the file to view. Sample Review of an Undergraduate Paper Level Reviewer 4 comments: Comment: This is an excellent report dealing with significant technical matters. I find no fault whatsoever with the methods, data analysis, or conclusions. The work, as with all work coming from this particular group, is fundamentally sound. My comments here are concerned solely with the organization of the blogger.com Size: KB 22/09/ · Second, I ponder how well the work that was conducted actually addresses the central question posed in the paper. (In my field, authors are under pressure to broadly sell their work, and it's my job as a reviewer to address the validity of such claims.) Third, I make sure that the design of the methods and analyses are appropriate. - McGlynn
No comments:
Post a Comment